IV crush: right on direction, still losing
Earnings can move a stock exactly the way you expected and still hand you a loss on your call. This module shows why with numbers.
3 min read4-question quiz140 XP
Before a known event such as earnings, the market raises implied volatility for expirations that include it. After the announcement the uncertainty is resolved, and IV collapses. That drop is called IV crush. It removes extrinsic value from every option, including yours.
The setup (all model values)
- Stock
- $100, earnings after tomorrow's close
- You buy
- 7-day 100 call at 80% IV (event-inflated)
- Premium
- $4.45 per share = $445 per contract
- Implied 7-day move
- 100 x 0.80 x sqrt(7/365) = about $11.08 (11%)
- Expiry breakeven
- $104.45
What happens next day
- Result
- Stock beats expectations and rises 3% to $103. You were right.
- IV after the event
- Falls from 80% to 40%
- Days left
- 6
- Call is now worth
- $3.96
- P&L
- $3.96 - $4.45 = -$0.49 per share = -$49 per contract
You were correct about direction and lost money. The stock moved 3% when the market had priced 11%. You bought a call priced for a much bigger move than occurred.
| Stock price | IV stays 80% | IV falls to 60% | IV falls to 40% |
|---|---|---|---|
| $95 | -$246 | -$331 | -$403 |
| $97 | -$173 | -$268 | -$358 |
| $100 | -$33 | -$135 | -$238 |
| $103 | +$141 | +$43 | -$50 |
| $106 | +$347 | +$262 | +$194 |
| $111 | +$747 | +$693 | +$665 |
Read down the right-hand column. With IV at 40% after the event, this call needs the stock above roughly $103.60 the next day just to break even. That is a +3.6% move needed to profit after a +3% move failed to.
Interactive payoff - Black-Scholes
Call bought before earnings
- Buy 1 x 100 call (7 days, event IV)
- P&L now
- −$50
- P&L at expiry here
- −$145
- Entry
- $445.43 debit
- Breakeven (expiry)
- $104.45
- Max profit
- Unlimited
- Max loss
- $445
- Delta / Gamma
- 73.1 / 6.25
- Theta/day | Vega/pt
- −$15.32 | $4.36
Theoretical mid prices, flat IV, 4% rate, no dividends, no fees. Real fills are worse.
What to do with this
- Compare the implied move to your own estimate. If the options market prices an 11% move and you expect 3%, buying the call is paying for something you do not believe in.
- Know that sellers have a different risk. Selling premium into earnings collects the inflated IV, but one outsized gap can cost many times the credit.
- Consider structures that reduce vega. A debit spread sells a call against the one you buy, so the IV drop hurts less. You still pay for being wrong, but not as much for the crush.
- Or simply skip the event. Not trading is a position. The cleanest way to avoid IV crush is to not hold long premium through the announcement.
Recap
Key takeaways
- 01IV is inflated before known events and collapses after. Long premium holders lose that value even when the stock moves their way.
- 02Direction is only one of three things you must be right about. Magnitude relative to the implied move matters as much.
- 03Compare the implied move to your expectation before buying. If you expect less than the market, buying is paying for a view you do not hold.
- 04Spreads reduce vega exposure; they do not remove the risk of being wrong.
Terms in this lesson
- IV crush
- The sharp fall in implied volatility after a known event resolves, removing extrinsic value from options.
- Expected move
- A one-standard-deviation range implied by IV: price x IV x sqrt(days / 365). A yardstick, not a prediction.
- Vega
- Change in option price per one-point change in implied volatility. Positive for long options.
- Debit spread
- A spread that costs money to open. Max loss is the debit; max profit is width minus the debit.