TAPE

Exercise, assignment, and the real cost of trading

Most positions are closed, not exercised. But you need to know what happens if you hold to the end, and what the bid-ask spread takes from you every time.

2 min read4-question quiz110 XP

Exercise and assignment

Exercise is the buyer using the right. Assignment is the seller being told to perform. When a buyer exercises, the clearing system assigns the obligation to a seller of that option, so a seller does not choose or know in advance who is on the other side.

A short call that is assigned means you deliver 100 shares at the strike. A short put that is assigned means you buy 100 shares at the strike. If you do not hold the shares or the cash to settle, your broker may close the position for you, sometimes at a bad price.

Settlement styles differ by product.
StyleMeaningCommon examples
AmericanCan be exercised any time up to expiryOptions on individual US stocks and most ETFs, including SPY and QQQ
EuropeanExercised only at expiryCash-settled index options such as SPX
Physical settlementShares change handsEquity and ETF options
Cash settlementDifference is paid in cashIndex options such as SPX

Exercising a long option early usually throws away its extrinsic value. Selling the option instead captures it. That is why most traders close positions rather than exercise them.

Bid, ask, and what you actually pay

Every option has a bid (what buyers will pay) and an ask (what sellers want). You buy at the ask and sell at the bid. The midpoint is a convenient reference, not a price you are owed.

Worked example: the spread is a cost

Bid / Ask
$1.00 / $1.20
Mid
$1.10
Spread
$0.20 per share = $20 per contract
Spread as % of mid
0.20 / 1.10 = 18.2%
Round trip at market
Buy at 1.20, sell at 1.00 if nothing else changes: -$20 per contract

For the trade to break even, the option must rise by about the full spread before you exit. A wide spread is a tax you pay before the market has a chance to be right.

Liquidity checks

  • Spread as a percent of mid. Tight is cheap. Wide is expensive. Compare the dollar spread to your expected gain.
  • Open interest. Contracts outstanding. Higher means more people to trade with.
  • Volume. Contracts traded today. Open interest can be stale; volume shows what is live now.
  • Order type. Use limit orders. A market order on a wide spread can fill far from the mid.

Recap

Key takeaways

  1. 01Exercise is the buyer's choice. Assignment is the seller's obligation, and the seller does not choose when.
  2. 02SPY and QQQ options are American-style and physically settled. SPX options are European-style and cash-settled.
  3. 03Closing a long option usually beats exercising it, because exercise forfeits extrinsic value.
  4. 04The bid-ask spread is a real, immediate cost. Measure it as a percentage of the mid before every entry.

Terms in this lesson

Exercise
The buyer using the right to buy (call) or sell (put) at the strike. Usually forfeits remaining extrinsic value.
Assignment
The seller being required to perform after a buyer exercises: deliver shares on a short call, buy shares on a short put.
Bid-ask spread
The gap between the highest price a buyer offers (bid) and the lowest a seller asks. You pay it every time you cross it.
Open interest
The number of contracts currently outstanding. Higher open interest usually means easier trading.
Volume
The number of contracts traded in a session. Shows live activity, unlike open interest, which can be stale.
Limit order
An order to buy or sell at a specified price or better. Protects you from filling at a poor price on a wide spread.